Talkback for article: 209, July2001
Compiling, Configuring and Installing a fully-working Customized Linux Kernel
From: chme <chme(at)linux.se>
[ date: 2001-07-14 ]
Hm ... I think every how-to article is good, since it helps taking the newbie fear of linux away.
To call this article "extremely detailed" is a bit misleading I think. You don't really explain what each step does, since it would take a lot of space and effort to explain how the kernel works, how modules work, and so on.
If this was the first article I read about how to compile a kernel, I would never have been able to understand what I did afterwards, and the kernel would probably not have worked.
I think a longer article that took more time to explain each step in newbie terms would have been a lot better. For instance, what does 'make bzImage modules' do? It is not obvious to a newbie.
Why don't you work on it a bit and post an updated version? I think the text is worth some more time and effort!
From: pete <plavelle1(at)firstlinux.net>
[ date: 2001-07-16 ]
Brilliant article, realy detailed. but just one critisism. It would have been good if you had covered more than one distro, such as slackware for example.
For people like myself who have had some experience with kernel compilation this its not so much a problem as I compiled my first kernel in slackware, but it would seem a bit daunting to newbies migrating from OS'es such as Windows 98/2000
But then again who am I to critisise. Keep up the good work m8
From: Brian Kelsay <bkelsaynospam(at)home.com>
[ date: 2001-07-18 ]
I like seeing the full commands to type in the terminal, that is always more helpful than seeing "make a backup copy of the file." I would like to see some explaination of the options in compiling a kernel, and examples of why (you touched on speed and size) to compile your own kernel.
You also might want to include some details on obtaining a new kernel if this is geared to the newbie. They may have never used an FTP client, so a couple of example commands might help.
From: Yogesh Sharma <yog_sliet(at)yahoo.co.in>
[ date: 2001-07-24 ]
linux is exellent for study
From: Wilfredo Perez G <oxana(at)hispavista.com>
[ date: 2001-08-15 ]
Por favor quisiera que me diguen como configurar el Kernel del Red Hat 7.1 para el IPv6. Les agradesco mucho por la respuesta, hasta pronto.
From: luc <luc.neulens(at)acunia.com>
[ date: 2001-10-06 ]
Good as a reminder for an experienced linux user, but not for a newbie who will not know what he īs doiing
From: Guido Schalckens <guido(at)schalckens.telenet.be>
[ date: 2001-11-23 ]
hello. I am a complete newbie. I will save this document for later (many years from now). I am not going to touch the kernel I have now (RedHat 7.1).
From: Mauricio Vega <mavricio(at)vtr.net>
[ date: 2002-01-02 ]
I think the article provides just an idea of how easy is to compile a custom Linux Kernel. In my case, the article was a guide to do it, no more. I use Slackware 8 and the sources come with the config file of the pre-compiled kernel, so you have a guide or a backup if you mess up.
Anyway, the article helped me to compile a kernel to view ntfs partitions and to use my dear SoundBlaster AWE32 and to remove the configurations for the hardware that I don't have.
My suggestion for the author is: Please write an update of this article describing how to "play" with the options of configuration.
My suggestion to the newbies is that they don't have reasonable reasons to not try to compile their own custom kernel, so do it.
Greeting from Chile.
From: Lucas <mail(at)lucasrosenthal.de>
[ date: 2002-01-03 ]
it's a really good article, specially for a newbie like me. Thank You.
From: Anoop <anoop_chandran_79(at)yahoo.com>
[ date: 2002-01-10 ]
describing the steps involved in compiling the new kernel 2.4.x for a pentium 4 machine is highly appreciated ,especially the MTRR ,APIC,MSR etc..
BTB it's a good article .
[ date: 2002-04-01 ]
Why compile SMP into your kernel when you only have 1 processor.
Don't compile stuff into the kernel that you don't need.
From: Val <vall(at)home.com>
[ date: 2002-06-13 ]
This is a great article. Even if you are a newby you could see that compiling a kernel isnt as daunting as it sounds. In this way it gives hope and motivates people to learn those things which they didnt understand. I am going to meess around with this in order to make a kernel for a different target. It would be usefull to see some explanations of the different options during config.
Greetings from Oz
From: barkha agrawal <mailbarkha(at)yahoo.com>
[ date: 2002-10-26 ]
this is a really good stuff.
it helped me a lot in my project on distributed file systems.
From: ank <aank1(at)hotmail.com>
[ date: 2003-01-22 ]
You have my admiration for your qualifications and for your skills.
[ date: 2003-11-02 ]
Thank you for this document. Among others i think it's good for a newbie to have this first step documentation. Why ?
This makes possible to go forward in solving an instant problem.
I believe newbie in linux does not mean "stupid" so maybe the newbie is able to use search engines of the web and seek the information he needs !
I think the aim of this document is a starter, i don't understand all this criticism which is not contructive.
I met few how-to talking about the kernel compiling but they are too wide and touching so much things that in the end you are not able to remember even how the how-to was starting.
Conclusion, keep going in your idea which is the one wich will stop this silly masturbating of linux users believing that they are gurus. Even if they are, this population is making that linux is a looser by hiding behing excessive complicating things.
Linux needs all but to be simple !!!
As idiots like me needs simple things this is the only way to make your favorite penguin a success otherwise you will get lost.
Thank you for your work :)
From: thebirdman <no_aol(at)AOL.com>
[ date: 2003-12-14 ]
good article man...I like U'r examples, however i think u could have elaborated just a bit more on what certain commands were doing. I bet u got tired half way thru the doc. I think it showed as u'r style got a little lazy....but u held in there man.
I am a newbie and I do understand a bit better now that I have read U'r writing. I thank-U for your time and effort that U put forth to help humanity.
Other talkbacks: Portugues Russian Francais
Due to the increased amount of web spam we have deciced to
removed the talkback posting possibility. You can read old talkbacks
but you can no longer post new ones.
Please contact webmaster(at)linuxfocus.org if you have any questions with regards to this talkback
lftalkback version 3.10